How We Review Supplements
Last updated
Every review on HCD Health follows the same process, so scores are comparable across products and you can check our work.
Step 1: Read the label
We take the full ingredient list and doses from the brand's own published supplement-facts panel or official sales page, and note the date. If the brand hides doses inside a "proprietary blend", we say so, because it makes it impossible to compare the product with research.
Step 2: Check each main ingredient against human research
For the 3 to 5 ingredients that drive the product's claims, we search PubMed, the Cochrane Library and the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. We prefer, in order:
- systematic reviews and meta-analyses of human trials,
- randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in people,
- smaller or observational human studies.
Animal and test-tube studies are noted but never treated as proof that something works in people. We compare the dose in the bottle with the dose used in the studies, because a tiny "sprinkle" of a researched ingredient is a common marketing trick.
Step 3: Fact-check the marketing claims
We pull the main promises from the official sales page and rate each one:
- Supported: consistent evidence from human trials at a similar dose.
- Mixed evidence: some positive human trials, some negative, or small effects.
- Weak evidence: mostly animal, test-tube or very small studies.
- Not supported: no meaningful evidence, or the claim contradicts the evidence.
Step 4: Price, refunds and fine print
We record the official price tiers and shipping cost on the check date, and work out the cost per day. We read the refund policy to find out whether opened bottles count and who pays return shipping.
Step 5: Safety
We list known side effects and interactions for the main ingredients, using NIH and peer-reviewed sources, and flag groups who should avoid the product (for example, people on blood thinners or diabetes medication, or during pregnancy).
Scoring
Each product gets four sub-scores out of 10, combined into an overall score:
| Sub-score | Weight | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
| Evidence for ingredients | 40% | Quality of human research for the main ingredients, at the doses used |
| Label transparency | 20% | Are all doses disclosed? Any proprietary blends? |
| Value for money | 20% | Cost per day against simpler alternatives with similar evidence |
| Safety profile | 20% | Known side effects, interactions, and how clearly they're disclosed |
Rough guide: 8+ means solid evidence and a fair price. 6 to 7.9 means some evidence but real trade-offs. Below 6 means mostly marketing.
What we don't do
- We don't run our own lab tests, and we don't pretend to.
- We don't publish customer testimonials, because we can't verify them.
- We don't let commission rates affect scores or rankings.
Updates
Prices, formulas and research change. We re-check reviews regularly. The "Updated" date on each page shows the last full check. See our editorial policy.